
As teachers, we often face the challenge of balancing our need for control with children’s need for writerly independence. While parameters are important to young writers, giving them the freedom to reinterpret, reimagine (or reject) a teacher- or scheme-chosen topic can lead to extraordinary results [LINK]. Consider this example from a teacher named Reed whose class trip to a fishing boat became the foundation for a wonderfully diverse set of manuscripts.
When asked to write about their school trip, one student asked if it would be alright to “pretend I’m a lobster being interviewed,” while another wanted to write about a dead seal they had discovered on the beach instead. Reed’s response was inspiring: she praised their originality and highlighted how one topic can spark so many different ideas. This approach, allowing independence to flourish within a shared framework, is a powerful reminder for us as educators. Here’s how you can replicate this strategy in your own classroom, turning teacher (or scheme) controlled writing units into opportunities for independent discovery and self-expression.
1. Start with a common prompt
Provide students with a topic, prompt or idea as a starting point. This might be a school trip, classroom activity, your wider curriculum topic, the book you’re reading together, or even a common theme like ‘revenge’ or ‘celebrations’.
Example: “Let’s think about our class trip to the beach. What did we see? What did we do?” Starting with a shared foundation gives students a springboard for their ideas while ensuring everyone has a common understanding of the project.
2. Host an ‘Ideas Party’
To spark children’s creativity, invite them to brainstorm their own ideas with their friends on flipchart paper. We call this having an Ideas Party. As a writer-teacher, you can spend time with each group and take part in the party too! On the flipchart paper, write the phrase: ‘I could write about…’ Children are welcome to draw or write their potential ideas onto the paper. Example:
- Being a lobster being interviewed
- The seal we found on the beach
- How the waves sounded
- A mermaid story



Here are some examples of Ideas Parties undertaken in Nursery, KS1 and KS2.

Here’s an example of children having an Ideas Party in response to reading ‘Leon & The Place Between’ by Angela McAllister
3. Foster a sense of ownership
Once students have brainstormed, emphasise that their unique perspectives are valuable. You might say: ‘Our prompt was the same, but your ideas have made it so special! I can’t wait to read all the different pieces of writing…’. This helps students feel confident in pursuing their own ideas, even if they differ from their teacher’s (or the scheme’s) expected idea.
4. Celebrate the results by taking a ‘Writing Register’
Take time to showcase the variety of responses by taking a Writing Register. This is where you write up your class’ names and ask them for a working title for their piece. Start with your most confident children until everyone has given you a title for their project. Like Reed, celebrate the diversity of thought by saying something like: “Isn’t it wonderful that from the same prompt, we have so many different ideas!”

An example of a completed Writing Register for a short-story project. The initial prompt shared by the teacher was ‘celebration’

An example of a completed Writing Register for a discussion project.
5. Encourage independence in future projects
This method of blending structure with independence can be applied to any genre or writing project. By giving students the option to use, reinterpret, or reject your prompt in their own way, you empower them to think creatively while still addressing the purpose for the writing project.
Why this matters
When we allow students to explore their own perspectives, we teach them that their voices matter [LINK]. A simple writing assignment becomes an opportunity for discovery, self-expression, and creative thinking. As Reed’s class demonstrated, even a shared experience like a school trip can inspire wildly different but equally wonderful writing ideas. The beauty of such an approach is that children who want to follow their teacher’s idea can do so while others can politely reject their teacher’s idea while offering up their own promising alternative.
By embracing this approach, you’re not just teaching students how to write – you’re teaching them to see the world through their own unique lens. And that is the heart of true writerly apprenticeship.
***
For more, download our publication: No More: ‘I Don’t Know What To Write About’ [LINK]. Our publications are free for our members. To become a member, click here.








